Post-16 reform must make vocational education a genuine first choice

As England prepares for significant reform of post-16 education, Richard Harry, our Executive Director: Qualifications and Assessment, argues that greater recognition of vocational education must be matched by rigorous, manageable qualifications that give learners clear routes into further study, training and employment.

For too long, vocational education has risked being talked about as an alternative to the academic route rather than a valuable pathway in its own right.

That is why the UK Government’s renewed determination to put technical and academic education on an equal footing matters.

In July, Prime Minister Andy Burnham said Britain must ‘value the hard hat every bit as much as the graduation cap’, arguing for an education system based on parity between academic and technical routes.

Education Secretary Lucy Powell was equally clear that every young person should be able to see a route to success, whatever their talents or ambitions.

Those comments demonstrate a clear desire for change - and one we strongly welcome.

But parity cannot simply be declared. If vocational pathways are to command the same confidence as traditional academic routes, the qualifications underpinning them must have the quality, rigour and relevance to make that ambition a reality.

That also means addressing the complexity that has developed within post-16 vocational education.

Over time we have seen different qualifications, of different sizes and levels, offered by different awarding organisations.

Compare that with the relative simplicity and widespread understanding of A Levels and it is perhaps unsurprising that vocational routes can be more difficult for learners, parents and employers to navigate.

That complexity may also have made it harder for vocational qualifications to command the recognition they deserve.

Reform therefore provides an opportunity for greater clarity and consistency.

At the heart of that should be a simple principle: a qualification should not merely demonstrate what somebody has learned. It should help them take the next step.

That might mean progression to further or higher education, an apprenticeship, further occupational training or moving directly into employment.

Different learners will take different routes and have different ambitions. Our qualification system needs to recognise that rather than attempting to force everybody down the same pathway.

This is where the emerging suite of qualifications, including V Levels, Foundation Certificates and Occupational Certificates, has the potential to make an important contribution.

They form part of a wider attempt to create clearer pathways through post-16 education while maintaining the choices learners need.

Increasing the rigour of vocational qualifications is important if we want learners, employers and the wider education system to have confidence in them. But there is an important caveat.

Reform has real consequences for the colleges and other centres that will ultimately deliver these qualifications.

Some proposed changes to qualification design, particularly around external assessment and assessment by examination within V Levels, will create additional pressures for centres.

That message has come through clearly in our conversations with the sector.

There is widespread support for high-quality vocational qualifications and ensuring they command the confidence and recognition they deserve. At the same time, colleges are operating in an environment where capacity and resources are already under considerable pressure.

Greater rigour is positive. A stronger focus on vocational education is positive. But changes to assessment and delivery have resource implications and those need to be understood.

We have seen similar issues through our experience of qualification reform in Wales. Many of the same messages are now being heard from post-16 providers in England.

As awarding organisations develop new qualifications, manageability therefore has to sit alongside quality and rigour.

The real test of reform, however, will be what it means for learners.

A successful post-16 system cannot simply offer a wide range of qualifications. Learners need to understand where those qualifications can take them.

For some young people, A Levels will continue to provide the right route. For others, a technical or vocational pathway will be better suited to their talents, interests and career ambitions. Neither should automatically be regarded as more valuable than the other.

What matters is that qualifications are high quality, recognised and capable of opening doors.

That also means ensuring vocational qualifications have genuine occupational relevance. Employers need confidence that learners progressing into their sectors have developed appropriate knowledge and skills, while learners need confidence that the time and effort they invest will help them progress.

Collaboration between awarding organisations, employers and education providers is therefore essential.

At Eduqas, our approach is based on co-construction, bringing employers into the development process so qualifications reflect the realities of industries and occupations.

We can build on sector relationships, similarly to those developed through our work on T Levels, while colleges and lecturers bring the equally important perspective of understanding learners and what it takes to deliver qualifications effectively.

There is also a much bigger economic issue behind these reforms.

Across the economy, employers continue to talk about skills shortages and difficulties recruiting people with the capabilities they need.

Qualifications cannot solve those challenges on their own. But they are an important part of the answer.

A qualification system that responds to economic change, provides clear progression routes and gives learners skills valued by employers can create a stronger connection between education and the world beyond it.

Eduqas is particularly well placed to contribute to that challenge.

We are one of a small number of awarding organisations with experience spanning A Levels, T Levels and Applied Generals. Through WJEC, we also bring recent experience of significant qualification reform in Wales.

That gives us an understanding not simply of individual qualifications, but of the whole learner journey and how different qualifications need to work alongside one another.

We will bring that experience to the development of V Levels, Foundation Certificates and Occupational Certificates, while continuing to listen to employers, colleges and lecturers.

Most importantly, success should be judged by what happens to learners.

If, in the years ahead, young people can look at post-16 education and see clear, respected routes into further study, training and employment, with vocational education regarded as a positive first choice rather than a second option, then this reform will have achieved something significant.

That is the opportunity now in front of us.

To learn more about qualification reform with Eduqas, visit our dedicated webpage.